PDF Download The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn
How if your day is started by checking out a book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn However, it remains in your gizmo? Everyone will certainly always touch as well as us their gadget when awakening and in morning tasks. This is why, we expect you to likewise review a publication The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn If you still confused how to get guide for your gadget, you can follow the means below. As below, we offer The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn in this internet site.
The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn
PDF Download The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn
Why ought to wait for some days to obtain or receive the book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn that you order? Why must you take it if you could get The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn the much faster one? You could find the same book that you get here. This is it the book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn that you could obtain straight after buying. This The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn is popular book on the planet, of course many people will aim to have it. Why don't you come to be the very first? Still puzzled with the means?
Do you ever recognize the e-book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn Yeah, this is an extremely intriguing publication to read. As we informed recently, reading is not sort of commitment activity to do when we have to obligate. Checking out must be a habit, an excellent habit. By checking out The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn, you could open up the new globe as well as obtain the power from the globe. Everything could be obtained with the book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn Well in short, publication is quite effective. As just what we supply you here, this The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn is as one of reviewing publication for you.
By reading this e-book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn, you will obtain the very best point to get. The brand-new point that you don't need to spend over cash to get to is by doing it alone. So, exactly what should you do now? Go to the link web page and download and install guide The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn You could get this The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn by on-line. It's so easy, isn't it? Nowadays, technology really assists you activities, this online book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn, is too.
Be the first to download this e-book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn and allow reviewed by surface. It is quite simple to review this book The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn because you don't should bring this printed The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn anywhere. Your soft data publication can be in our device or computer system so you could appreciate reviewing all over and every single time if required. This is why lots numbers of people likewise read the publications The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn in soft fie by downloading and install guide. So, be one of them which take all benefits of reading guide The Lost Battalion: Controversy And Casualties In The Battle Of Hue, By Charles Krohn by on-line or on your soft data system.
In 1968 in South Vietnam, a U.S. infantry battalion was ordered to charge a fortified North Vietnamese Army force 200 yards away over an open field with no artillery or air support. The defenders had every advantage. The Americans started moving across the field just before noon, every man a target. By the time they reached the tree line at the other side of the open field, nearly one half of the 400-man battalion was a casualty. Nine long, agonizing hours afterwards, U.S. artillery units began support fire, although the units remained desperately short of ammunition. The entrapped men saw their fate: death or captivity. Help from headquarters was neither offered or available.
The following night the battalion commander decided to make a run for it. It was a gamble with high stakes. But the battalion did make it through enemy lines to a mountaintop where the NVA could not follow. When the Lost Battalion finally escaped encirclement, after nine hours with no artillery or air support, and 30 hours of fighting against an enemy that outnumbered them three to one, the tragic episode disappeared from official memory and relevant U.S. Army records--as if nothing had happened. Krohn tells the whole story--and it tells it with the words of those present. That some of the testimony comes from those responsible is remarkable.
- Sales Rank: #2363808 in Books
- Published on: 1993-11-19
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 10.00" h x 6.50" w x 1.25" l, 1.22 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 224 pages
From Publishers Weekly
Krohn, who served as the unit's intelligence officer, draws an instructive comparison between two drastically different battles fought in early 1968 by the 2nd Battalion, 12th Regiment, 1st Cavalry Division. In the first, 2/12 successfully withstood a North Vietnamese assault on firebase LZ Ross in the Que Son Valley. Essential to that success was the abundance of artillery and air support and adequate ammunition. Monsoon weather, logistical bungling and poor command decisions at divisional level, dictated that 2/12 went into the second battle, outside of Hue City, without air or artillery support. The battalion was surrounded by the enemy and began to run out of ammunition. As casualties mounted, the unit commander, Lt. Col. Richard Sweet, decided to walk his troops out of the encirclement under the cover of darkness. Led by "the ultimate point man," Private Hector L. Cammacho, the bold maneuver succeeded. Krohn, a retired lieutenant colonel, calls for stateside training in which infantry battalions practice operations after vital support systems have faltered. His first-rate account demonstrates what can happen in combat when such systems do break down. Photos.
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Most Vietnam War oral histories deal more with individual experiences than specific events. The opposite is true in this book, which details a tragic military foul-up. As the Tet Offensive commenced, U.S. Marines were trapped in Hue without packs, air and artillery support, or sufficient ammunition. The 2nd Battalion, 12th Cavalry, was ordered to relieve them. Although a large enemy force blocked the battalion, the commanding general ordered it to proceed. Stumbling upon the North Vietnamese Army's headquarters, the battalion was surrounded and ultimately suffered 60 percent casualties. As battalion intelligence officer, Krohn is on a mission to lay blame where blame is due. Yet what should have been a scintillating war narrative becomes disjointed in the heat of his crusade. The action pauses while every order, every act by higher-ups is examined. Recommended only for libraries with special interests in the army and Vietnam.
- Richard Paul Snyder, Cty. of Los Angeles P.L., Lakewood
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"Anyone who has fought will recognize this as a real story about some very tough battles, written by a real soldier who was there. Fortunately, Charles Krohn is a keen observer who with just the right amount of trenchant humor tells a tragic story, tells it extremely well, and lets the emperor appear unclothed whenever it is appropriate to do so. A superb chronicle about a handful of brave men who did what they were asked to do despite the odds against them--on both sides."- General Donn A. Starry, USA-Ret.
Most helpful customer reviews
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful.
New generation finds lessons from the past.
By CPT Eric Remoy
I was the 2-12 Cav S-2 from January 2000 to July 2001, this book is everything a staff officer should and must read. I came upon the book because it was about my unit, it has been deliberately overlooked by army professional reading lists. Mr. Krohn's account highlights the unfathomable value of honesty and integrity in our profession; the lack thereof causes lives. An excellent read, a heart-wrenching story even today for those who were not there. "Those who do not study the past are doomed to repeat it." Thank you Mr. Krohn.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful.
Should Be Required Reading for Generals and Politicians
By zendawg
Krohn was the intelligence officer for a battalion of the fabled 1st Cav Air Mobile Division that got caught with its pants down when the NVA staged its surprise attack during the Tet holiday ceasefire. As far as I can tell it was not his fault that the attack came as a surprise. They knew something was coming but not how bad it would be. The division had moved its headquarters and left its big guns behind. When the NVA launched its offensive Krohn's battalion was sent on a march to relieve the Americans in Hue. They left their backpacks with their ponchos and other critical gear behind to be flown in later. They marched into an NVA regiment that was guarding the NVA command and control center for the attack on Hue and were ordered to march across an open field and attack, as the author says much like in the Charge of the Light Brigade. (I am not a vet so please excuse me if I don't have the terms down). Krohn's battalion was surrounded and outnumbered, with limited ammo, food, water and other necessities. The Army which usually provided heavy artillery support couldn't because the tubes were not in place, and when they did arrive the ammo still hadn't come in. Krohn's battalion fought off repeated attacks until they were so weakened they knew they would die if they stayed, and in a heroic night march they slipped through the NVA lines.
Krohn is a talented writer who had a central vantage point to a fiasco. He clearly loves the men he served and suffered with and is bitter, with justification, at the REMF's that let them down. One of his friends in the rear was so enraged at the lack of support that he pulled a .45 on another officer to get supplies out to the field. The battalion suffered 60% casualties. Krohn was discouraged from writing this book because it made the top brass in the division look so incompetent. He wrote it anyway and has done a great service. If Clinton had read it maybe the fiasco recounted in Blackhawk Down would have been avoided, and probably a lot of other similar tragedies that have not yet come to light.
This review is based on the new paperback edition.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful.
Telling it like it is!
By George James Kalergis
I read this book and found it to be right on target. It is an accurate and straight forward account. I don't see the author "pointing fingers" or on any kind of crusade to blame, as some have alluded to. He just told it "the way it was". Those that comment critically about the detailed description of the staff and command actions behind the scene either are ignorant or have their own agenda. IMHO
Commanders are not perfect, we all make mistakes and I think the author is more forgiving about some of them than I am. In my experience, the kind of miscommunication and foresight described in the book, happened all to frequently. It is unthinkable that a maneuver battalion would be put in that position without immediate artillery support! Heads should have rolled! From my experience in my year with the 1st Cav, the lessons from the supply and artillery coordination blunders were available to be learned all along, but certainly in the months leading up to TET.
I was an FO/Door Gunner experience with the 1st of the 9th for 30 days, on the ground as an FO with the 5th of the 7th and with a firing battery of the 1st of the 21st for the calendar year of 1967. I was involved with quite a few actions that turned out less than well as a direct result of the kind of poor command decisions and staff planning that are encountered and describe so well.
There are so many lessons that can be learned from this book, but in all probability will be ignored. My hat is off to the author for having the courage and persistence to "tell it like it was"!
George Kalergis
LTC FA (ret)
The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn PDF
The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn EPub
The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn Doc
The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn iBooks
The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn rtf
The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn Mobipocket
The Lost Battalion: Controversy and Casualties in the Battle of Hue, by Charles Krohn Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar